Saturday, September 1, 2012

Justice at last

Dr Mohammad Manzoor Alam 

Courtesy:Sify News.

  Dr.Mohammad Manzoor Alam expresses satisfaction at the conviction of 32persons in the Naroda Patiya massacre of 97 Muslims in 2002.*

The conviction of Babu Bajrangi, who openly boasted about the Naroda Patimurders on TV and that of Dr Maya Kodnani, a gynaecologist and minister of state in Modi government for sometime, is the highlight of the special court’s judgment nailing down 32 offenders for the ethnic cleansing of Naroda Patiya locality in Ahmedabad in 2002.

This is not, thankfully, is the first such judgment in cases relating to
the massacre of Muslims in Gujarat, which was termed by a panel of retired
high court judges as genocide. A substantial number of people have already been awarded life sentence in other cases related to Gujarat 2002.

This judgment as well as the earlier ones related to Gujarat 2002 have
brought a sense of relief to the victims as well as other Muslims all over
India. Along with this a new confidence has arisen in judiciary’s
impartiality and fair play as well as regard for the due process of law.

The greatest advantage of such judgments is that the victims who have seen
their near and dear ones killed, their homes torched, their belongings
destroyed and their dignity trampled under feet, are quietened. Only when
justice is denied to such people they seek recourse to extrajudicial
measures, blinded by hurt and anger as they are. In that respect, it is a
great relief to Muslim elders, who have got a basis to argue with the
unfortunate youth who have seen everything in their life destroyed by
state-sponsored rioters. Now, we have the argument that justice is not dead
and no victim of atrocities should think of doing justice himself.

Dr Kodnani’s conviction is a clear proof that Modi thought the direct
involvement of this woman in the mass killing was a badge of honour. She
had to leave government only when she was arrested as an accused in the
heinous crime.

The BJP argument that Kodnani was not a minister when she committed the
crime is an example of the Sangh’s queer logic. What it goes on to show is
that Narendra Modi and his party have no respect for human life, especially
if it happens to be a Muslim’s life. This also confirms the worst fears
about the state’s involvement in the crime.

Babu Bajrangi’s case is even worse. This man has openly been boasting about
how he killed Muslims. He knew all along that the state would not touch him
as it was being run by the same people who had organised the monumental
crime. That he has been proven wrong goes to the credit of the Special
Court. An equal measure of credit also accrues to the social and political
activists (almost all of them Hindus) who fought relentlessly to get
justice for the victims.

Any rejoicing at this moment will be premature as the people who did all
this are capable of making as ass of the law. The culprits of Babri Masjid
demolition and associated killings are not only roaming free, but had the
honour of becoming Union Cabinet ministers. Killers of Hashimpura, Meerut,
Maliana and a thousand other riots were never brought to book.

However, the reckoning has begun. Among the perpetrators of Gujarat 2002
Sardarpura massacre 31 culprits were awarded life term; among Ode village
killers 18 got life term and five got seven years in jail; in the second
Ode massacre nine got life term; in the Deepda Darwaza killings 21 got life
term and in Naroda Patiya 32 have got convicted. At the time of writing
this Kodnani had been awarded 28 years in jail and Bajrangi a life term.
Others were to follow.

In all this no one has been awarded a death sentence, unlike Godhra train
blasts case in which 11 were sentenced to death and 20 got life term.

Please contact author "Institute of Objective Studies, New Delhi" <>

Contents of the article rest on the author.
Photo:Courtesy:Sify  News

Bangla Deshi’s in India: Myth and Reality

Ram Puniyani
Ram Puniyani

The Assam violence between Bodos and Muslims, alleged by many to be Bangldeshi infiltrators, has a long chain of repercussions. The number of dead is nearly eighty. Killings are continuing and the people who have been displaced have been over 4 lakhs. There is no exact statistics to tell us how many of the displaced are Muslims and how many are Bodos, still roughly some investigators have put the figure of Muslims 80% and Bodos 20%. The few reports which have come out tell us that the condition of the all refugee camps is abysmal, much worse of those where Muslims are living. Meanwhile many a voices have come up to express their own opinions. The BJP leaders have strongly asserted that the whole violence is due to the Bangla Deshi infiltrators, whose number is estimated as per the flight of one’s imagination ranging from 10 million to 20 million or even more. It is alleged that they have encroached, taken over the land of the local natives, which is causing the dissatisfaction and so the hate for them. This hate in turn is at the root of violence. This is one case where displacement overshadows the violence.

Photo:Courtesy:The Hindu

The Election Commissioner H.S. Brahma, a Bodo himself, went to the extent of saying that these infiltrators have gone up in number and so have become aggressive and attacked the local Bodos. The other point of view is that despite the formation of Bodo Territorial Council, the Bodos did not surrender their arms, which was one of the conditions for accepting the demand of this regional council. There are voices from BJP stable that this is an issue of Nationalism, the one of Indians and the other of Bangladeshis. Some of them have voiced that these Bangla Deshis should be disenfranchised and not be permitted to vote. As such already many of them are not allowed to vote by putting them in the category of ‘D’ voters, i.e. doubtful voters. As per BJP and company it is Congress, which has been encouraging the Bangladeshis to infiltrate so that they can be used as the vote bank by the Congress. Not to ignore that since major number of those in relief camps is that of Muslims, some Bodo groups have warned that the Muslims should not be permitted to return to their original places.

Photo: Ritu Raj Konwar:Courtesy The Hindu
National Minorities Commission in its report has pointed out that there is no infiltration of Bangla Deshis as such and the issue is that between the Bodo ethnic groups, on one side and the Muslims, who have settled here from a long time, on the other. Before we come to the issue whether these are Bangla Deshi infiltrators, Bangldeshi migrants or the Muslims settlers from Bengal over a period of time, lets register that the Assam episode had a very painful after events. There were Hate emails, Hate web sites which warned the North Eastern people that revenge of Assam will be taken against them and this caused a mammoth exodus of North eastern people from all over, more particularly from Bangalore. The Web sites which did this dirty job, many of them have been blocked, it is said are from Pakistan, some 20% of the blocked sites are the one’s run by Hindutva groups also. Through leaflets and other mechanisms VHP and other groups are propagating that Hindus are being attacked by Muslims, the Bangla Deshi infiltrators.

Not to be left behind some orthodox, fanatic Muslim groups organized a protest rally in Azad Maidan of Mumbai, in which a preplanned act by a section of Muslims attacked the OB vans of media and the police officials. The restrained and effective leadership of Arup Patnaik was not to the liking of the communal elements and those politicking on the issue within the ruling party and so Mr. Patnaik has been punished by being kicked up, As such secular activists and large section of Muslims are in deep appreciation of Mr. Patnaik’s handling of the episode.

Coming back to the propaganda of Bangla Deshi infiltrators, many a researchers have proved on the basis of demographic data of last century in particular that the Muslims in the region are settlers from pre partition Bengal to begin with, later at the time of partition in 1947 and lastly at the time of Bangla Desh war in 1971. Assam accord of 1985 recognizes all those living in this area as the legal setters, most of the Muslim fall in that category. Not to deny that that some small number of illegal immigrants, the one’s forced to migrate for economic reasons is also there.
The change in demographic profile of Assam has taken place over a period of more than a century. It was mainly the British policy to release the pressure from the then Bengal province that they encouraged the Bengalis to settle in Assam. The last major migration has taken place around 1971, the Bangla war. After that the trickle has been there but the alleged infiltration is not there. Assam accord does recognize that all those who have settled before 1971 are legal Indian citizens, which most of the Muslims in Assam are. This is shown by the pattern of decadal growth in the region more particularly from 1950 onwards. The census figures clearly point out that after 1971; there is no major increase in the population of the area. The decadal growth in India, Assam, Dhubri, Dhemaji, and Karbi Anglong from 1971 to 1991 had been 54.51, 54.26, 45.65, 107.50, and 74.72 respectively. While the same in the decade of 1991-01 became 21.54, 18.92, 22.97, 19.45, 22.72 and in the decade of 01-11 it became 17.64, 16.93, 24.40, 20.30 and 18.69 respectively.  Shivam Viz in Myth of Bangla Deshi and Violence in Assam ( shows that the migration has taken place over a period of time and the increase of population stops after 1971.

If we just look at the decadal growth rates of population in two other districts of Assam, Dhemaji and Karbi Anglong, we will see that their growth rates in comparison have been more than twice that of Assam and substantially higher than even the ‘Muslim’ majority ‘border’ district of Dhubri. Yet, the Muslim population in Dhemaji and Karbi Anglong is minuscule. The Hindu population in these two districts is 95.94% and 82.39% Hindu respectively. Muslims constitute merely 1.84% and 2.22% respectively of their total populations, in spite of having consistent high decadal growth rates – Dhemaji touching 103.42% between 1961-71 and Karbi Anglong having a similar high of 79.21% between 1951-61. This should be testimony enough to show that there could be reasons apart from illegal immigration of Muslims behind a high decadal growth rate of population. In Assam there is a decline in the population in Kokrajhar, which is the seat of Bodo Territorial Council. It hasthe lowest population growth of 5.19%, from the earlier 14.49 per cent in 2001. 

Understanding the truth and deeper analysis of the demographic pattern of Assam is very essential to understand the nature of present carnage, which is more of a sectarian nature, a group trying to assert ethnic domination in the region. The underlying causes, lack of development of the region, absence of jobs, is creating more pressure on the land, and the ‘sons of the soil’ politics is being brought up in a very painful manner. Not only do we need to assuage the present violence, there is a need to bring in amity between different communities with proper development of infrastructure, which gives the opportunities to all the citizens of the area.   
Issues in Secular Politics
I September 2012
Response only to

Contents of the article rest on the author.